Verification and validation: Differences and definitions
What is the difference between verification and validation, and how are these terms defined? Even standards and regulations use the terms incorrectly or misleadingly. This article
Details1. Definitions
Medical software includes all software used for healthcare, particularly for medical devices or medical devices (embedded software), and software that is itself a medical device (standalone software).
IEC/CD1 82304-1 (Health Software – Part 1: General requirements for product safety) distinguishes between the following terms:
- HEALTH SOFTWARE
Software intended to be used specifically for maintaining or improving health of individual persons, or the delivery of care - MEDICAL SOFTWARE
Software intended to be used specifically for incorporation into a physical medical device or intended to be a SOFTWARE MEDICAL DEVICE - SOFTWARE MEDICAL DEVICE
Software intended to be a medical device in its own right - MEDICAL DEVICE SOFTWARE
Software intended to be used specifically for incorporation into a physical medical device
This clarifies that medical software can be a medical device but does not have to be.
Fig. 1: Medical software includes medical device software and software as a medical device (click to enlarge).
2. Regulatory requirements
a) Medical software – a medical device?
The question often arises as to when medical software meets the definition of a medical device. You can find a further discussion on this topic in the article on the classification of software as a medical device and in the article on the qualification and classification of IVD medical device software.
b) Regulations, laws, standards
Software that is a medical device or part of a medical device must meet the regulatory requirements:
- In Europe, the medical device regulations (MDR, IVDR) are relevant. However, these only contain relatively general regulations for software, which this article presents.
- IEC 62304 defines the life cycle processes for medical device software.
- IEC 82304-1 applies to all “health software”. IEC 82304-1 also requires conformity with the requirements of IEC 62304.
- There are also MDCG guidelines, e.g., MDCG 2019-11 and MDCG 2023-4.
- The FDA sets out specific requirements in its guidance documents, including specific requirements for medical software. It also answered many questions specifically about software as a medical device in this FAQ.
Further information
Read more about legally compliant software development and IEC 62304 here.
3. Support for medical device manufacturers
Benefit from the support of the Johner Institute:
- Do you have questions about developing and approving medical devices that contain or are software? Our free micro-consulting will provide you with answers.
- In the medical software compact seminar, you will acquire the prescribed competencies. You will learn about and fulfill the legal requirements for software development.
- The Medical Device University’s video training will help you to create a lean and IEC 62304-compliant “software file” step by step. In addition, a complete set of templates takes a lot of work off your hands.
- You can also benefit from the support of our experts. They will help you to document your software briefly, precisely, and in compliance with the laws and standards and prepare you for audits and tech file reviews.
- Have the IT security of your software evaluated using penetration tests.
Contact us right away so that we can discuss the next steps. This will ensure that the “approval” is a success and that your software or devices are quickly launched on the market.
Risk management in hospitals and at other operators
Laws require risk management in hospitals, especially in order to improve patient safety. Nevertheless, many hospitals find this difficult. This article presents the most important regulatory requirements and provides tips for implementation.
DetailsQualification and classification of IVD software
The qualification and classification of IVD software determine how and how quickly IVD manufacturers can bring their software to market and what costs arise for “approval.” This article will help you correctly qualify and classify IVD software, thereby avoiding regulatory problems and the resulting costs and delays.
DetailsSoftware life cycle: What is meant by this?
The Medical Device Regulation (MDR) (like the Medical Device Directive (MDD) and thus the Medical Device Act before it) requires manufacturers to comply with life cycle processes for their software. IEC 62304 and IEC 82304 also refer to software life cycle processes. But what is a software life cycle?
Level of Concern and Documentation Level: What the FDA wants to achieve with it
1. Documentation Level: End of Level of Concern On June 14, 2023, the FDA released the guidance document Content of Premarket Submissions for Device Software Functions. This document replaces the guidance document introducing the Level of Concern and only distinguishes between two classes.
DetailsSoftware maintenance: How to avoid typical audit pitfalls
Software maintenance is the phase in which software is further developed, e.g., with the objective of According to the FDA, 79% of all bugs occur during software maintenance. Accordingly, some regulations address this topic.
DetailsMDCG 2023-4 on combinations of MDSW and hardware
MDCG published guideline MDCG 2023-4 in October 2023 entitled “Medical Device Software (MDSW) – Hardware combinations – Guidance on MDSW intended to work in combination with hardware or hardware components.”
Off-the-Shelf Software (OTS) versus SOUP
Both the FDA and IEC 62304 recognize software developed by third parties. They refer to Off-the-Shelf Software (OTS) and Software Of Unknown Provenance (SOUP). What is the difference between OTS and SOUP? What do they have in common? What legal requirements do they have to meet? This article provides answers.
DetailsWhen can clinical studies be avoided for devices with artificial intelligence?
For manufacturers, the answer to whether and when clinical studies are necessary when using artificial intelligence in medical devices is relevant. After all, the duration and cost of bringing these devices to market depend on this. The good news in advance: there are cases where manufacturers can avoid clinical studies for devices with AI. This…
DetailsMedical device software PC: Software manufacturers, watch out!
The term “medical device PC” is not clearly defined. However, most people understand a medical device PC to be Depending on the constellation, manufacturers must fulfill different regulatory requirements. These are presented in this article.
Details